Welcome to 164 Church St. N., St. Marys. This extraordinary 1880 home was originally constructed by William Irvine, a local carpenter, with assistance from James Spearin, a carpenter from Limerick, Ireland who took possession in 1885. The construction of the home, with the yellow field brick and red brick quoins and voussoirs and semi-circular cranberry glass window over the entrance lend an impressive appearance, as do the very large windows on the 1990 addition at the back of the house, more than doubling the square footage. Highlights of the home include the original staircase with cherry handrail and octagonal tapered oak spindles, and wide-board trim. The addition ties in seamlessly to the original structure, featuring a two-story great room with stunning floor-to-ceiling gas fire place, enormous windows letting in abundant natural light, wood floors, and a back staircase leading to the upstairs bedroom hallway outside the Primary bedroom with Ensuite bath. An open walkway looking down onto the great room leads to the bedrooms and bathroom that are part of the original home. A walk-out basement has an office area, recreation room with gas fireplace & built-in bar area. The lot is huge, with potential for severance, and hosts breathtaking perennial gardens, pathways, hidden sitting areas and water features. A short walk south leads to historic downtown St. Marys with it's beautiful limestone structures, or you can meander one street over to walk the Grand Trunk Trail with breathtaking panoramic views of both town and country.
Fridge, stove, dishwasher, microwave, washer, dryer, green cabinet in upstairs bedroom (that matches the headboard), garage door opener and remote, laundry sink, water softener, sump pump, sewage pump, all light and ceiling fixtures, all window treatments and hardware, electric awning, all exterior water features & pumps, garden shed, all attached cabinets & shelving
Headboard in the upstairs (turquoise) room; Mirror in front hallway
Data was last updated October 22, 2026 at 01:15 AM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
36
Avg list price:
$714,950
Min list price:
$399,900
Max list price:
$2,649,900
Avg days on market:
74
Min days on market:
1
Max days on market:
727
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type
and located in
St. Marys. Average values are
derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by
the MLS® system.
This website may only be used by consumers that have a bona fide interest in the purchase, sale, or lease of real estate of the type being offered via the website.
The data relating to real estate on this website comes in part from the MLS® Reciprocity program of the PropTx MLS®. The data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed to be accurate.